276°
Posted 20 hours ago

Jemmy Button

£9.9£99Clearance
ZTS2023's avatar
Shared by
ZTS2023
Joined in 2023
82
63

About this deal

A wonderfully illustrated and written picture book for children that tells the story of a child taken from South America by New World Explorers to be taught the ways of the English.

I can see why contrasting illustration styles were chosen, but I would have preferred more representativeness. And, if O'run-del'lico was sold, how might that be indicative of British abuse of power (creating contexts in which native Yahgan people would voluntarily sell or feel forced into selling a child for a button)? I'd say this book will make a good addition to a kid's shelf (older children) but here's the thing, it'd be a shame to settle for the theme of adventure or only taking the text at face value.I spotted this at the library and thought it would make for a fun pairing with another book I’m reading, This Thing of Darkness, a chunky novel about Captain Robert FitzRoy’s expeditions to Tierra del Fuego (on one of which he was accompanied by Charles Darwin on the Beagle). Let it be a spark that opens up discussions on other topics such as the challenges and hardships assimilating to a culture, the tragedy of being separated from one's home and family- how about the parents/family?

He is given that name as he is taken from his island by aristocratic westerners who believe they can teach a feral person to be sophisticated in a more civilised society. Collaborating across continents, without a common language, Valerio'sprecision and Jennifer's primitive style have resulted in a story unlike any other. This may be a book that children are able to relate to particularly if they are new or have moved to a new area of for EAL children who are living in a different culture or experiencing different customs for the first time. I know that this is a book for children, and I appreciate that the stories of lesser-known figures in history are being told, but I can’t co-sign a book that presents the story of white men taking a child away from his parents and parading him around England like a pet or a side show, as a morally neutral event.But other than the author mentioning that the boy missed the boughs of the trees and the night sky on his island home, the reader is never told about the difficulties that he must have faced in trying to assimilate into white society. I found it truly hard to believe that his birth parents were not depicted visually (quite dehumanizing), and that they did not experience stress and loss--what did they think would happen if they didn't sell their child? What happened to the real Orundellico (aka Jemmy Button) had to have been a traumatic event, one I'm sure that must have left life-long scars.

Living on a “faraway island” a boy named Orundellico climbs the tallest trees, views the stars, listens to the ocean and wonders what’s “on the other side.ditanah orang nya tu pokoknya serba wah aja kaya amazing banget dengan segalanya baik kultur maupun teknologi.

The people who took him back to their land introduced him to so many new things and changed his style and his life in so many ways. The real Orundellico was taken from his people as a young boy and sent to England to be educated in Christianity and Victorian customs. I understand simplifying events for children, but here that’s to the point of historical inaccuracy. Reaching the other side of the ocean, Jemmy finds houses made of rocks “stacked in towers taller than the tallest tree.dan dari segi cerita yang emak al tangkap sangat2 pengambaran literasi poskolonial yang pastinya masih bisa dicerna dengan sederhana, yaitu ; sense of belonging. How people get places and how interconnected we are as a world would be a point that I would want to highlight. Jemmy Button, a native of Tierra del Fuego, was brought to England in the mid-1800s to be "educated and civilized.

Asda Great Deal

Free UK shipping. 15 day free returns.
Community Updates
*So you can easily identify outgoing links on our site, we've marked them with an "*" symbol. Links on our site are monetised, but this never affects which deals get posted. Find more info in our FAQs and About Us page.
New Comment